Head Coach: Herman Byers (113-29-7, 16th year)
Record: 10-0 (6-0 SIAC, 5-0 City)
Ranking: #1 in final INS ranking, final Litkenhous rating & final UP ranking
Championships: State, SIAC & City Champs
Results
* – denotes SIAC contest
| Date | Opponent | Score | Comment |
| Sep. 7 | Owensboro Catholic (Ky.) | W 41-0 | |
| Sep. 13 | @ Vincennes * | W 34-6 | |
| Sep. 20 | Muncie Central | W 26-0 | |
| Oct. 5 | @ New Albany * | W 39-6 | |
| Oct. 11 | Mater Dei * | W 33-0 | |
| Nov. 2 | @ Indpls. Cathedral | W 40-7 | |
| Nov. 8 | North | W 46-0 | |
| Nov. 15 | Memorial * | W 21-6 | |
| Nov. 19 | Central * | W 33-6 | |
| Nov. 28 | Bosse * | W 33-13 | Thanksgiving |
Individual Honors
- Bill Coleman
- Scholastic All-American
- AP All-State halfback
- INS All-State right halfback
- UP All-State right halfback
- All-SIAC halfback
- Sunday Courier & Press Consensus All-City halfback
- Courier All-City right halfback
- Evansville Downtown Quarterback Club All-City halfback
- Press All-City halfback
- Larry Coleman
- AP All-State tackle
- UP All-State tackle
- INS All-State second team tackle
- All-SIAC tackle
- Sunday Courier & Press Consensus All-City tackle
- Courier All-City right tackle
- Evansville Downtown Quarterback Club All-City tackle
- Press All-City tackle
- Frank DeMuth
- All-SIAC honorable mention center
- Courier All-City second team center
- Larry Duncan
- All-SIAC honorable mention guard
- Sunday Courier & Press Consensus All-City guard
- Courier All-City second team left guard
- Press All-City guard
- Fred Gross
- All-SIAC honorable mention quarterback
- Sunday Courier & Press Consensus All-City quarterback
- All-City quarterback (unknown selector)
- Courier All-City second team center
- Virgil Horne
- All-State (unknown selector)
- All-SIAC honorable mention tackle
- Sunday Courier & Press Consensus All-City tackle
- Courier All-City left tackle
- Evansville Downtown Quarterback Club All-City tackle
- Press All-City tackle
- Bernie Johnston
- All-SIAC guard
- Sunday Courier & Press Consensus All-City guard
- Courier All-City right guard
- Press All-City guard
- Tom Trainer
- AP All-State end
- INS All-State left end
- UP All-State second team end
- All-SIAC end
- Sunday Courier & Press Consensus All-City end
- Courier All-City left end
- Evansville Downtown Quarterback Club All-City end
- Press All-City end
4 pings
[…] 1957 Reitz Panthers […]
[…] 1957: Reitz 40, Indianapolis Cathedral 7 Once again ranked No. 2, the Panthers routed the Fighting Irish, a win that helped carry them to their second consecutive state title. […]
[…] 1957*: Reitz 33, Central 6 (SIAC game) […]
[…] 1957*: Reitz 33, Bosse 13 (SIAC game) […]