- Royce Ashby (2020)
- Galen Avery (2018)
- Gene Backes (2016)
- Jame Bateman (2016)
- Tim Bishop (2021)
- DeWayne Brantley (2021)
- Tyrone Browning (2016)
- Chuck Brunson (2021)
- Cory Brunson (2016)
- Kirk Brunson (2016)
- Tom Buck * (2016 & 2021)
- Herman Byers * (2016)
- Jim Byers * (2018)
- Austin Carlton (2016)
- Brian Claybourn * (2016)
- Ricky Crider * (2016)
- Mike Dassel (2021)
- John Elliott (2020)
- Pete Fisher * (2016)
- Marlon Flemming * (2016)
- Bob Gaddis (2016)
- Ryan Given * (2017)
- Ron Ham (2019)
- Beth Hagan (2016)
- Don Hansen * (2016)
- Andy Hape * (2016)
- Bill Hape (2016)
- John Hart * (2016)
- Nick Hart * (2016)
- Billy Hewig (2016)
- Allan Horn (2018)
- Mike Horn * (2017)
- Charlie Jackson (2019)
- Tolly McClatchy (2016)
- Dave McDonald (2018)
- Matt McIntosh (2016)
- Paul McIntosh (2016)
- Earl Milligan (2021)
- Bob Nelson (2021)
- Mark Nelligan (2021)
- Bob Padgett * (2016)
- Lloyd Pressley (2016)
- Duce Reeder (2016)
- Marc Schnarr (2018)
- Mick Schnell * (2016)
- Tim Shipp (2016)
- Don Siscel (2017)
- Bob Stephenson * (2016)
- Mike Volkman (2018)
- Don Wade (2018)
- Don Waterman * (2016)
- Doug Waterman (2018)
- Ed Wessel * (2016)
- Josh Whicker * (2016)
- Tom Wilson (2016)
* – also in the Reitz Football Hall of Fame
Other links of interest
- Official website for the Greater Evansville Football Hall of Fame
- Greater Evansville Football Hall of Fame to induct over a dozen Panthers into first class (4/15/16)
- Greater Evansville Football Hall of Fame announces eight more Reitz inductees (5/9/16)
- Greater Evansville Football Hall of Fame inducts 33 Reitz Panthers last night (10/10/16)
